Proposed successor question · unapproved
Will a released mathematics result have an independently reproduced formal proof by November 30?
This successor draft asks whether at least one qualifying result receives an independent successful proof check by November 30. No expectation or confidence has been approved for this wording.
Question ID formalization-v2 · version 2.0 · rubric SI-1.0.
Why a successor. The original headline mentions formal artifacts, while its criterion also requires an unaffiliated successful proof check. This proposed wording states the stricter milestone directly.
Read the preserved original question and expectation.
What would count
Met if at least one top-line result in the October 6 release has a publicly accessible formal proof added after the October 8 cutoff, with a recorded proof-checking command and successful run documented by a reviewer unaffiliated with OpenAI. Supporting lemmas alone do not count.
How a result would be judged
Use the repository's dated version history, linked proof artifacts, and the independent reviewer's public reproduction report. Missing independent reproduction by November 30 is not met; unavailable or conflicting records are ambiguous. Human editorial adjudication is required and has not occurred.
Deadline. 2026-11-30
Original source cutoff. 2026-10-08. This source basis does not claim a current outcome review.
Before this could become a forecast
Before activation, a human reviewer must check evidence through the actual activation date, approve the expectation and assign adjudication authority. This proposal is not a prospective scored forecast.
No separate adjudicator is assigned. No probability, calibration result or historical predictive skill is claimed.
What changed and what stayed fixed
The headline now names independent reproduction. The expectation is explicitly unapproved; the original confidence is not carried over. The original eligible results, proof requirement, unaffiliated reviewer, deadline, resolution wording and source are preserved. The earlier question remains accessible at its permanent URL.
Original primary source · The record · Current newsletter draft